In short
Would you rather is a game of impossible choices: someone gives you two options, like flying or being invisible, and you have to pick one and say why. Below are 250 original questions sorted by age (3 to 5, 6 to 8, 9 to 12 and teens) and by crowd (family night, the classroom, couples and work), plus funny, hard and deep sets. Every one is clean and kind, and none is about anyone's looks. Under 26 of them you'll find what real people picked when a pollster or a researcher asked the same thing or something close to it, with the source linked.
We read 17 of the pages that rank for this search before writing ours. Most cite nothing at all, and none of them reports what a real poll found. Most kids' lists have no ages on them, and several lists sold as "clean" or "for kids" include questions about bodies, kissing, jail or losing a parent. Many lean on movie franchises, celebrities and this year's apps, which date fast and leave the grandparents at the table out.
So every question here is original and built from things that won't date: animals, food, school, weather, travel and family habits. Kids get three age bands, matched to what research says children can do at each age. And where a pollster or a researcher asked people the same question, the answer is printed underneath, so the argument at the table has an ending.
What is a would you rather question?
A would you rather question gives you two options and makes you choose one: would you rather be able to fly or be invisible? What turns it into a game is the rule that you can't pick both or neither, and you have to say why. The phrase itself is everyday English. Cambridge Dictionary defines would rather as "used to show that you prefer to have or do one thing more than another". The game just makes the two things harder to choose between.
It's a family-table favorite. The Family Dinner Project, a nonprofit based at Massachusetts General Hospital, names Would You Rather as one of its two most popular dinner games and says it works for almost all ages. Teachers use it as well. Writing in Edutopia, teacher Peggy Grabish Clark describes asking upper-elementary students to explain their pick, which moves the game up Bloom's taxonomy of thinking skills.
Why is would you rather good for kids?
Because it's a conversation, not a quiz. In a 2018 study of 36 children aged 4 to 6, the number of back-and-forth turns they had with adults, more than the number of words they heard, was linked to stronger activity in Broca's area, a language region of the brain, and to higher verbal scores. That's a link, not proof of cause and effect, but it fits what Harvard's Center on the Developing Child calls serve and return: a child says something, an adult answers, and the child goes again.
A would you rather question is a serve almost every child returns. The "why?" afterward does the work. It asks a child to give a reason for a choice, which is exactly what first-grade writing standards ask for (see the age table below). And at dinner, it gets the adults talking too.
How do you play would you rather?
One person reads a question with two options. Everyone picks one, out loud or by pointing, and nobody is allowed to say "both" or "neither". Then each player gets one sentence to defend their pick, and anyone can try to talk them into switching sides. There's no score unless you want one, and no wrong answer, only a weak reason. Allow about a minute per question with reasons, so 15 to 20 questions fill a 20-minute round and 10 cover a short car ride.
| Way to play | Best for | How it works |
|---|---|---|
| Around the table | Families, dinner | Read one question, go around the table, and everyone answers with one reason before the next one. |
| Pick a side of the room | Kids, classrooms | Point to one wall for the first option and the other wall for the second. Everyone walks to their side, then each side picks a speaker. |
| Guess my answer | Families, couples | Before someone answers, everyone else predicts their pick. A point for each right guess. |
| Change my mind | Teens, adults | The smaller side gets thirty seconds to win people over. Count again and see who switched. |
| Write your own | Kids 7 and up | Each player writes one question on a slip of paper. Mix them in a bowl and draw. |
| One a day | Car rides, lunchboxes | One question on a sticky note in the lunchbox, or one per hour on a road trip. |
If a child insists on "neither", let them change one detail of one option and then pick. The change they make usually tells you more than the original answer would have. For a holiday round, our Christmas this or that questions are sorted the same way, by age and crowd.
What age can kids play would you rather?
From about three, if the two options are things a child knows and can picture. The American Speech-Language-Hearing Association lists giving reasons as a communication milestone between ages 2 and 3 and suggests offering young children a choice, like milk or water, instead of a yes-or-no question. The AAP's HealthyChildren.org advises limiting a toddler's food choices to two options.
Imagined situations take longer. Preschoolers can already answer simple "what if" questions about a scene they've just watched (Harris, German and Mills, 1996), but on the trickiest "what if" questions, 9- to 11-year-olds did about as well as 6-year-olds in one study, and only 12- to 14-year-olds came close to adults (Rafetseder, Schwitalla and Perner, 2013). That's why the kids' sets below are split by age, and why the hardest dilemmas are saved for teens and adults.
| Age | What they can do | Questions that fit |
|---|---|---|
| 3 to 5 | Choose between two familiar things and say which they like. Regret about a choice shows up by about 5 (Weisberg and Beck, 2010). | Two things they can picture: puppy or kitten, slide or swings. |
| 6 to 8 | Give a reason. Common Core asks first graders to state an opinion and supply a reason, and second graders to link reasons with words like "because" (Common Core W.1.1 and W.2.1). | Pretend situations: a treehouse or a houseboat, talking to dogs or to birds. |
| 9 to 12 | Weigh a real trade-off, though the hardest "what if" questions still trip many of them up (Rafetseder and colleagues, 2013). | Something to give up for something to get: best player on a losing team or worst on a winning one. |
| 13 and up | Think through situations that don't or can't exist, and their wider consequences (OpenStax Lifespan Development). | Freedom, friends, the future, and the hard and deep sets. |
Would you rather questions for kids ages 3 to 5
Keep these to two things a young child already knows, so they can answer by pointing or with one word. A three-year-old picks what they like; asking "why?" afterward is where the talking starts.
- Would you rather jump in puddles or roll down a hill?
- Would you rather have a pet puppy or a pet kitten?
- Would you rather eat pancakes or waffles?
- Would you rather go down the slide or ride the swings?
- Would you rather be a lion or a monkey for a day?
- Would you rather build a sandcastle or a snowman?
- Would you rather ride on a train or on a boat?
- Would you rather paint with your fingers or with a big brush?
- Would you rather blow bubbles or fly a kite?
- Would you rather hear a bedtime story or sing a bedtime song?
- Would you rather splash in the bath or run through the sprinkler?
- Would you rather wear your pajamas all day or your favorite costume all day?
- Would you rather visit the zoo or the farm?
- Would you rather have spaghetti or pizza for dinner?
- Would you rather drive a fire truck or a garbage truck?
- Would you rather squeak like a mouse or trumpet like an elephant?
Would you rather questions for kids ages 6 to 8
Six-to-eight-year-olds can hold a made-up situation in their heads and argue for it, so these lean on pretending. Ask for one reason per answer and they'll usually give three.
- Would you rather live in a treehouse or on a houseboat?
- Would you rather be able to talk to dogs or understand what birds are saying?
- Would you rather have a robot that makes your bed or a robot that packs your lunch?
- Would you rather explore a cave or climb a sleeping volcano?
- Would you rather have a slide from your bedroom to the kitchen or a trampoline for a bedroom floor?
- Would you rather be the fastest runner in your school or the best jumper?
- Would you rather swap places with your teacher for a day or with a grown-up at home?
- Would you rather find a secret door in your house or a treasure map in your yard?
- Would you rather have a pet that glows in the dark or a pet that can sing?
- Would you rather visit the moon or the bottom of the ocean? Grown-ups are split on the Moon: 44% of US adults would go if a safe return were guaranteed and 40% wouldn't (YouGov, 2026).
- Would you rather invent a new candy or a new toy?
- Would you rather live inside your favorite book or your favorite game?
- Would you rather have a snow day every Monday or a pool day every Friday?
- Would you rather go to camp in the woods or camp at the beach?
- Would you rather breathe underwater or jump as high as a house?
- Would you rather ride a giant turtle or a giant butterfly?
- Would you rather have a zip line in the yard or an ice rink in the yard?
- Would you rather speak every language or play every instrument?
Would you rather questions for kids ages 9 to 12
Tweens like a real trade-off: something to give up for something to get. These have no obvious right answer, which is the point.
- Would you rather be the best player on a losing team or the worst player on a winning team?
- Would you rather be really good at one thing or pretty good at everything?
- Would you rather have no homework for a year or no tests for a year? Adults asked to imagine being a student again split almost evenly: 42% would take weekly tests and no homework, 41% daily homework and no tests (YouGov, 2023).
- Would you rather spend a day in a castle in the year 1300 or a city in the year 2300?
- Would you rather be able to pause time or rewind it by ten seconds?
- Would you rather design a theme park or design a video game?
- Would you rather get $50 today or $100 a month from now?
- Would you rather win the science fair or the spelling bee?
- Would you rather spend a summer working on a farm or on a fishing boat?
- Would you rather remember everything you read or everything you hear?
- Would you rather decorate your room any way you want or double your allowance?
- Would you rather be an astronaut or a video creator with a million followers? In a 2019 Harris Poll for LEGO, 29% of US kids ages 8 to 12 put YouTuber or vlogger among their dream jobs and 11% astronaut. In China, 56% picked astronaut (BBC Newsround).
- Would you rather give up dessert for a month or screens for a week?
- Would you rather get called on in every class or never get called on at all?
- Would you rather lose your voice for a day or your sense of taste for a day?
- Would you rather be the oldest kid in your class or the youngest?
- Would you rather have a famous best friend or be famous yourself?
- Would you rather spend Saturday with friends doing something with no screens or with friends playing on screens? Most kids pick no screens: 72% of US kids ages 8 to 12 said they'd rather spend most of their time with friends doing things in person, without screens, than together on screens and devices (The Harris Poll, 2025).
Funny would you rather questions for kids
Silly beats gross. Every one of these gets a laugh without anyone being the joke. For more laughs sorted by age, try our jokes for kids and riddles for kids.
- Would you rather sneeze confetti or burp bubbles?
- Would you rather walk like a crab or quack like a duck all day?
- Would you rather have a bike horn that laughs or shoes that squeak when you walk?
- Would you rather have a dinosaur the size of a hamster or a hamster the size of a dinosaur?
- Would you rather only be able to whisper or only be able to shout?
- Would you rather wear your shoes on your hands or your mittens on your feet?
- Would you rather have a toothbrush that talks or a pillow that sings?
- Would you rather have a cat that barks or a dog that meows?
- Would you rather eat ice cream with a fork or soup with chopsticks?
- Would you rather live in a bounce house or a giant cardboard fort?
- Would you rather hop everywhere or skip everywhere?
- Would you rather giggle every time someone says your name or sneeze every time you see something yellow?
- Would you rather sleep on a giant marshmallow or sit on a cloud?
- Would you rather have to say "banana" after every sentence or clap before every word?
- Would you rather have a parrot that repeats your secrets or a goldfish that tells bad jokes?
- Would you rather wear a cape to school every day or a crown to school every day?
- Would you rather ride a bike with square wheels or a wagon pulled by a goat?
- Would you rather wear a snorkel mask to dinner or a bike helmet to bed?
Animal would you rather questions
Animal questions work for every age and sneak in a little science. After each answer, ask what the animal actually uses that ability for.
- Would you rather swing through trees like a monkey or swim like a dolphin?
- Would you rather have a giraffe's long neck or a cheetah's speed?
- Would you rather see in the dark like an owl or hear in the dark like a bat?
- Would you rather have a pet penguin or a pet sloth?
- Would you rather spend a day as a bee or a day as an ant?
- Would you rather be a whale for a day or an eagle for a day?
- Would you rather have a kangaroo's pouch or a turtle's shell?
- Would you rather follow a herd of elephants for a day or a pack of wolves?
- Would you rather change color like a chameleon or have eight arms like an octopus?
- Would you rather have a dog that can drive or a cat that can cook?
- Would you rather sleep hanging upside down like a bat or standing on one leg like a flamingo?
- Would you rather have a dog's nose or an eagle's eyes?
- Would you rather be a beaver building a dam or a squirrel burying nuts for winter?
- Would you rather live with a family of meerkats or a pod of dolphins?
Food would you rather questions
Everybody has an opinion about food, which makes these the easiest questions to start a dinner with.
- Would you rather have breakfast for dinner every night or dessert for breakfast once a week?
- Would you rather eat only green foods or only orange foods for a week?
- Would you rather have unlimited pizza or unlimited tacos?
- Would you rather give up cheese or give up chocolate?
- Would you rather have a fridge that refills itself or an oven that cooks anything in one minute?
- Would you rather drink only water or only milk for a month?
- Would you rather eat dinner blindfolded or wearing oven mitts?
- Would you rather eat your favorite meal every day or never eat the same meal twice?
- Would you rather put sprinkles on everything or ketchup on everything?
- Would you rather pick your own apples or catch your own fish for dinner?
- Would you rather cook in a fancy restaurant or run your own food truck?
- Would you rather eat food that's always a little too spicy or always a little too plain?
- Would you rather live in a house made of cookies or drive a car made of cheese?
- Would you rather have pineapple on every pizza or no pizza ever again?
- Would you rather have cake or pie at every birthday? Cake wins, 47% to 39%, among US adults (YouGov, 2016).
Superpower would you rather questions
The oldest argument in the game. Fly or be invisible has its own radio episode (see the history section), and people still split on it.
- Would you rather be able to fly or be invisible? When Marist asked Americans to pick one of five powers in 2018, flying (17%) beat invisibility (12%), but time travel (29%) beat both (Marist Poll).
- Would you rather read minds or see the future?
- Would you rather teleport or time travel? Time travel, 29% to 15%, in the same 2018 Marist Poll.
- Would you rather be super strong or super fast?
- Would you rather control the weather or talk to animals?
- Would you rather walk through walls or shrink to the size of a bug?
- Would you rather be able to heal people with a touch or never get sick yourself? Healing was the most wanted of six superpowers in a 2017 poll, picked by 37% of US adults, far ahead of flight at 8% (YouGov).
- Would you rather make it snow whenever you want or make the sun come out whenever you want?
- Would you rather stretch like rubber or bounce like a ball?
- Would you rather copy any skill you watch once or learn any language in a day?
- Would you rather have X-ray vision or night vision?
- Would you rather make plants grow in seconds or fix any machine by touching it?
- Would you rather never need to sleep or never need to eat?
- Would you rather have a great superpower nobody knows about or a so-so superpower everybody knows about?
- Would you rather be a superhero with no sidekick or a sidekick with the best gadgets?
Adventure would you rather questions
Knight or pirate, astronaut or deep-sea diver: these are the questions kids answer fastest, because most of them already have a favorite world. (Here are the worlds we paint kids into.)
- Would you rather be a knight guarding a castle or a pirate captain sailing the sea?
- Would you rather be an astronaut fixing a space station or a diver exploring a shipwreck?
- Would you rather fly a dragon over the mountains or ride a unicorn through a meadow?
- Would you rather explore a jungle or cross a desert on a camel?
- Would you rather live in an underwater palace or a castle in the clouds?
- Would you rather dig up a dinosaur bone or discover a new planet?
- Would you rather be a fairy who makes flowers bloom or a wizard who makes thunderstorms?
- Would you rather be a ninja nobody can see or a cowboy nobody can catch?
- Would you rather drive a race car or fly a plane?
- Would you rather be a firefighter for a day or a doctor for a day?
- Would you rather find a pirate's treasure chest or a dragon's egg?
- Would you rather sail a ship through a storm or steer a sleigh through a blizzard?
- Would you rather discover a new kind of fish or a new kind of bug?
- Would you rather have a dinosaur for a best friend or a robot for a best friend?
- Would you rather be the hero of a fairy tale or the hero of a space story?
Knight, pirate or astronaut? Make it real
Ask which world they'd pick, then let them star in it. Upload one photo and we paint your child as the hero of that world, from a pirate cove to a dragon kingdom to outer space, printed as a puzzle, a canvas or a blanket. You approve a free, watermarked proof before anything prints.
Would you rather questions for students
For a morning meeting, a substitute's first ten minutes or an opinion-writing prompt. Have students move to one side of the room, then write two sentences defending their side.
- Would you rather have recess twice as long or lunch twice as long?
- Would you rather have a class rabbit or a class lizard?
- Would you rather do a science experiment that fizzes or one that glows?
- Would you rather take a field trip to a museum or to a factory?
- Would you rather write a story or draw a comic?
- Would you rather take a test outside on the grass or inside a pillow fort?
- Would you rather start school an hour later or finish an hour earlier?
- Would you rather have a robot teacher or a teacher who used to be an explorer?
- Would you rather work at a standing desk or on a beanbag?
- Would you rather have show-and-tell every day or a talent show every month?
- Would you rather solve one really hard puzzle or ten easy ones?
- Would you rather read a book about dragons or a book about real animals?
- Would you rather be line leader or door holder?
- Would you rather read a paper book or an ebook? Among US kids ages 6 to 17 who had read an ebook, 45% preferred print, 16% ebooks and 38% had no preference (Scholastic Kids & Family Reading Report).
- Would you rather have a four-day school week with longer days or a five-day week with shorter ones?
Would you rather questions for family night
These work across three generations: nobody needs to know a show, a song or an app. Let the youngest answer first and the oldest go last. For questions that draw out a grandparent's stories instead, try our questions to ask your grandparents.
- Would you rather have a family movie night or a family game night?
- Would you rather take a road trip together or a train trip together?
- Would you rather cook dinner together or build a blanket fort together?
- Would you rather start a family band or a family sports team?
- Would you rather vacation at the beach or in the mountains?
- Would you rather camp in the backyard or stay in a cabin?
- Would you rather swap chores with each other for a week or swap bedtimes for a week?
- Would you rather plant a garden together or paint a mural together?
- Would you rather take one big trip a year or lots of little day trips?
- Would you rather learn a recipe from the oldest person here or a game from the youngest?
- Would you rather pick dinner every night or pick the music on every car ride?
- Would you rather visit the place your family came from or a place nobody in the family has been?
- Would you rather take a family photo in the same spot every year or somewhere new every year?
- Would you rather spend a rainy Saturday doing a puzzle or baking something?
- Would you rather know what your birthday present is ahead of time or be surprised? Most grown-ups want the surprise: in a German study, 59.6% would not want to know their Christmas presents in advance and only 6.8% would (Gigerenzer and Garcia-Retamero, 2017).
Would you rather questions for teens
Teens will play if the questions take their world seriously: phones, friends, sleep, freedom and what happens after school.
- Would you rather text your friends or see them in person? Teens are split: 35% of US teens named texting their favorite way to talk with friends and 32% in person. In 2012, in person led with 49% (Common Sense Media, 2018).
- Would you rather be the funniest person in the room or the smartest?
- Would you rather have a car but no license for a year or a license but no car?
- Would you rather go to a concert alone or to a party where you know one person?
- Would you rather skip one class forever or retake any test once?
- Would you rather give a speech at graduation or sing at the talent show?
- Would you rather go viral once for something you're proud of or never go viral at all?
- Would you rather live in a big city or a small town?
- Would you rather travel for a year after school or start your career a year early?
- Would you rather never do chores again or never have a curfew again?
- Would you rather have a perfect memory or perfect pitch?
- Would you rather always be five minutes early or always five minutes late? More adults run early than late: 43% say they usually arrive early to social plans, 40% right on time and 11% usually late (YouGov, 2019).
- Would you rather star in a movie or write it?
- Would you rather know what everyone thinks of you or never find out?
- Would you rather spend the summer working at a theme park or at a beach?
- Would you rather plan a trip with friends or join one somebody else planned?
- Would you rather be great at a sport or great at an instrument?
- Would you rather have the same best friend your whole life or a new best friend every few years?
100 more questions for the family table
Curious Questions is our own deck of 100 conversation cards, written so a teenager and a grandparent can both answer every one. One of its five themes, Imagine, is all what-ifs, made-up worlds and silly superpowers. Ages 14+, printed to order in Madison, Wisconsin, $39 with free US shipping.
Funny would you rather questions for adults
Clean enough for the office, a baby shower or the in-laws.
- Would you rather fight one horse-sized duck or a hundred duck-sized horses? Senator Jeff Flake passed this one to Neil Gorsuch at his 2017 Supreme Court confirmation hearing, on behalf of his teenage son. Gorsuch: "you got me" (hearing transcript).
- Would you rather always have one song stuck in your head or never be able to remember a song at all?
- Would you rather narrate your life out loud or have a laugh track follow you around?
- Would you rather always hit reply-all or never be able to undo anything?
- Would you rather have autocorrect change every name to a dinosaur or every verb to "dance"?
- Would you rather sneeze every time you fib or hiccup every time someone else does?
- Would you rather lose your keys every morning or one sock from every pair?
- Would you rather have a theme song that plays when you walk into a room or a fog machine that follows you?
- Would you rather always be a little too hot or always a little too cold?
- Would you rather have hiccups for a whole day or feel like you're about to sneeze for a whole day?
- Would you rather speak only in rhyme or sing everything you say?
- Would you rather have every door you open creak loudly or every chair you sit on squeak?
- Would you rather wear socks with sandals forever or a tie to every beach day?
- Would you rather have a coffee maker that gives pep talks or a toaster that reads you the weather?
- Would you rather only be able to text in emojis or only be able to call?
Hard would you rather questions
Hard questions are ones where both answers cost something you care about. A few of these have been asked of thousands of people, and the results are linked below each one.
Impossible choices
- Would you rather have more time or more money? Across five studies of 4,415 American adults, 64% chose money, but the people who chose time were happier (Hershfield, Mogilner and Barnea, 2016).
- Would you rather lose all your old memories or never make new ones?
- Would you rather change one thing in your past or see one thing in your future?
- Would you rather never be able to lie or never be able to tell when someone else is lying?
- Would you rather win something in a way people will argue about forever or not win at all? Asked whether they'd rather win something in a controversial way or not win at all, 36% of US adults chose not winning and 33% the disputed win (YouGov, 2021).
- Would you rather redo your teen years knowing what you know now or skip ahead ten years?
- Would you rather have a job you love with an hour's commute or a job you're bored by five minutes from home?
- Would you rather hear everyone's thoughts or have everyone hear yours?
- Would you rather live without music or without TV and movies?
Deep ones
- Would you rather know the date you will die or never know? In a representative German sample, 87.7% said they would not want to know, and only 4.2% said yes (Gigerenzer and Garcia-Retamero, 2017).
- Would you rather live a long, ordinary life or a short, extraordinary one?
- Would you rather have modest success in your lifetime and be forgotten soon after, or no success in your lifetime and be remembered for generations? A dead heat: 32% to 32% among US adults, with 36% unsure (YouGov, 2023).
- Would you rather be very smart and often sad or less smart and usually happy? Asked the blunter version (smart and sad, or dumb and happy), US adults split 35% to 37%. People with graduate degrees chose smart and sad, 48% (YouGov, 2022).
- Would you rather live to 120 or to an ordinary old age? 56% of US adults said they would not want treatments that let them live to 120 or more, and 38% would. Yet 68% thought most other people would want them (Pew Research Center, 2013).
- Would you rather have a big house where you need a car for everything or a small home where you can walk to shops and school? Big house, 55% to 44%, in a 2026 survey of 8,512 US adults (Pew Research Center).
Would you rather questions for adults
Life, travel, money and Sunday mornings. These suit a dinner party or a long drive.
- Would you rather be a morning person or a night owl? Close: 40% of US adults call themselves morning people and 37% night people (AP-NORC, 2025).
- Would you rather have summer all year or fall all year? A tie: 28% of Americans name summer their favorite season and 28% fall, with spring at 30% (YouGov).
- Would you rather travel back in time or forward in time? The past, 49% to 30%, among US adults (YouGov, 2021).
- Would you rather spend a year living abroad or a year traveling around the US?
- Would you rather get a raise or an extra week of vacation every year?
- Would you rather read the book first or see the movie first?
- Would you rather have a home library or a home theater?
- Would you rather give up coffee or give up dessert?
- Would you rather be famous or be rich? Not close in Britain: 87% chose rich and 3% famous (YouGov GB, 2016).
- Would you rather cook every meal or clean up after every meal?
- Would you rather take a vacation with no phone or a staycation with no chores?
- Would you rather own a cabin in the woods or an apartment by the sea?
- Would you rather be the best cook in your friend group or the best storyteller?
- Would you rather be a cat person or a dog person for the rest of your life? When Gallup made Americans choose, 70% said dog person and 20% cat person (Gallup, 2006).
- Would you rather vacation somewhere new or somewhere you already love? Somewhere new, 61% to 25% (YouGov, 2019).
- Would you rather spend most of your free time alone or with other people? Alone, narrowly: 54% to 46% (Ipsos, 2024).
Would you rather questions for couples
Clean questions for a date night or a long drive, and a quick way to learn something new about someone you already know.
- Would you rather plan every date night or be surprised every time?
- Would you rather take a weekend away just the two of you or a big trip with friends?
- Would you rather go back to where you first met or recreate your first meal together at home?
- Would you rather share one dessert or each order your own?
- Would you rather take a dance class together or a pottery class together?
- Would you rather get a handwritten letter or a playlist made just for you?
- Would you rather have a song that's "yours" or a dance you always do at weddings?
- Would you rather road-trip with no map or fly somewhere with no plan?
- Would you rather adopt a dog together or plant a garden together?
- Would you rather stay up late talking or get up early for a sunrise walk?
- Would you rather let your partner choose your outfits for a week or your meals for a week?
- Would you rather celebrate a little every month or go big once a year?
- Would you rather relive your first date or spend one day at your 50th anniversary?
- Would you rather always drive or always pick the music?
- Would you rather keep every card you've given each other or every photo you've taken together?
Would you rather questions for work
Icebreakers for a team meeting, picked so nobody has to share anything personal.
- Would you rather have unlimited snacks at work or a quiet nap room?
- Would you rather hold meetings standing up or walking outside?
- Would you rather work from a mountain cabin or a seaside café for a month?
- Would you rather give a talk to 500 strangers or to everyone you've ever worked with?
- Would you rather have no meetings on Fridays or no email on Mondays?
- Would you rather your job came with a uniform or a theme song?
- Would you rather present your work out loud or write it up?
- Would you rather have the best chair in the office or the best view?
- Would you rather plan the office party or run the cleanup?
- Would you rather swap jobs with the CEO for a day or with the newest hire?
- Would you rather have a coworker who's always early or one who's always cheerful?
- Would you rather learn a new skill at work or teach one?
What do most people pick?
Here are the questions above where a pollster or a researcher asked real people the same thing, or something very close to it. Each figure links to the original source. Two patterns stand out: in one German study few grown-ups wanted to know what was coming, and the superpower adults want most isn't flying.
| Question | What most people picked | Source |
|---|---|---|
| More time or more money? | Money, 64%, but the people who chose time were happier | Hershfield and colleagues, 2016 |
| Travel back in time or forward? | Back, 49% to 30% | YouGov, 2021 |
| Know the date you'll die, or not? | Not, 87.7% to 4.2% | Gigerenzer and Garcia-Retamero, 2017 |
| Know your presents in advance, or not? | Not, 59.6% to 6.8% | Gigerenzer and Garcia-Retamero, 2017 |
| Fly or be invisible? | Fly, 17% to 12%, but time travel beat both at 29% | Marist Poll, 2018 |
| Which superpower most? | Healing, 37%, with flight at 8% | YouGov, 2017 |
| Weekly tests or daily homework? | Tied, 42% to 41% | YouGov, 2023 |
| Live to 120, or an ordinary lifespan? | Ordinary, 56% to 38% | Pew Research Center, 2013 |
| Big house far out, or small and walkable? | Big house, 55% to 44% | Pew Research Center, 2026 |
| Dog person or cat person? | Dog, 70% to 20% | Gallup, 2006 |
| Morning person or night owl? | Morning, 40% to 37% | AP-NORC, 2025 |
| Vacation somewhere new or somewhere familiar? | New, 61% to 25% | YouGov, 2019 |
| Friends in person or together on screens? (kids 8 to 12) | In person, 72% | The Harris Poll, 2025 |
| Text friends or see them in person? (teens) | Texting, 35% to 32% | Common Sense Media, 2018 |
How do you write a good would you rather question?
A good would you rather question splits the room. If nearly everyone picks the same side, it's a quiz with an obvious answer. The trick is to make both options tempting, or both a little painful: "more time or more money" works because people want both, and several of the polled questions above come close to 50-50.
Wording matters more than you'd expect. In a classic 1981 experiment, 72% of students chose a sure plan when it was described as saving 200 people, but 78% chose the gamble when the same two plans were described by how many people would die. Same choice, different words, opposite answer. So if a question lands lopsided, try rewording one side before you throw it out.
Four rules we used for every question on this page:
- Make the two options about the same size. "Fly or be invisible" works. "Fly or have a slightly better pencil" doesn't.
- Make it concrete. "Live in a treehouse or on a houseboat" beats "live somewhere unusual". Kids especially need something to picture.
- Keep it kind. No questions about anyone's body, looks, family or friends getting hurt. Learning for Justice gives teachers the same advice for get-to-know-you games: stick to interests, hobbies and family, not clothing or appearance.
- Leave out anything that dates. A question built on a celebrity, a show or this year's app stops working next year, and the grandparent at the table won't know it.
Kids can write their own with one sentence frame: "Would you rather ___ or ___?" Ask them to test it on two people first. If both pick the same side, the second option needs to get harder.
Where did would you rather come from?
Nobody invented it. The phrase is centuries old, the question is at least as old as Shakespeare, and the book and board game that made it a party staple came out in the late 1990s. The word rather goes back to Old English hrathor, which meant something like "sooner", and is recorded before the year 900. Chaucer's good Parson, reluctant to excommunicate anyone over unpaid tithes, "rather wolde he yeven" (would rather give) to his poor parishioners.
An early famous would you rather question is a political one. In Julius Caesar, a play from around 1599, Brutus asks the Roman crowd after the murder: "Had you rather Caesar were living, and die all slaves, than that Caesar were dead, to live all freemen?" It's the game's structure exactly: two options, both with a cost, and a crowd forced to pick.
Who made the Would You Rather book and board game?
An earlier Would You Rather book is a picture book. English author-illustrator John Burningham published Would You Rather... in 1978, asking children whether they'd rather eat spider stew or slug dumplings, and ending with the option of going to sleep in your own bed.
The version most adults know came in 1997, when David Gomberg and Justin Heimberg published Would You Rather...?: Over 200 Absolutely Absurd Dilemmas to Ponder with Plume. It sold more than 300,000 copies, and in 2004 the pair started their own press to publish more. Around the same time, Randy Horn turned a UCLA business-plan class project into a would you rather board game from his company, Zobmondo. The two sides fought for years over the name. A federal appeals court noted along the way that collections of bizarre "would you rather" questions had appeared in print before the book's authors began using the phrase as a brand.
Why is flying or invisibility so famous?
Its best-known airing is a 2001 radio story, and pollsters have kept asking it since. In This American Life episode 178, "Superpowers", first aired on February 23, 2001, John Hodgman asked people at parties, dinners and wedding receptions to pick flight or invisibility, with one rule: "You can't have both." In his terms, invisibility "means the power to become transparent at will, including your clothing", and flight comes "at speeds up to 1000 miles per hour."
Hodgman's survey was never a real poll. Ira Glass introduced it as "an unscientific survey", and the only pattern Hodgman reported was a loose one: men leaned toward flying and women toward invisibility, "though there are lots of exceptions." Real polls since then suggest both are second choices. Given five powers, Americans put time travel first, at 29% (Marist, 2018). Given six, they put healing first, at 37% (YouGov, 2017).
Where did the horse-sized duck question come from?
It's older than most people think. The question, whether you'd rather fight one horse-sized duck or a hundred duck-sized horses, can be traced to at least October 2003, when the British blog City of Sound wrote up a reader's query spotted in the previous day's Metro newspaper. It became a Reddit in-joke years later.
Its most famous outing was President Obama's Reddit "ask me anything" on August 29, 2012, where it was one of the most popular questions. He answered 10 questions in 30 minutes, and it wasn't one of them. Neil Gorsuch did get asked. At his Supreme Court confirmation hearing on March 21, 2017, Senator Jeff Flake passed the question on from his teenage son, and Gorsuch replied that he was "very rarely at a loss for words. ... But you got me" (hearing transcript).
What is the hardest would you rather question?
The best-known candidate is the trolley problem: would you let a runaway trolley hit five people, or steer it onto a track where it hits one? It comes from the philosopher Philippa Foot's 1967 paper in the Oxford Review. Judith Jarvis Thomson gave it its name in 1976 ("I like to call this the trolley problem, in honor of Mrs. Foot's example"), and she named the version where a bystander throws a switch, "Bystander at the Switch", in her 1985 Yale Law Journal article.
MIT's Moral Machine, which posed trolley-style dilemmas for self-driving cars, collected 40 million decisions from people in 233 countries and territories (Nature, 2018), though its players were mostly young, male and college-educated. Among professional philosophers in the 2020 PhilPapers Survey, 63% accepted or leaned toward switching the trolley, and 13% toward not switching. It's not a question for the kids' table, which is why it's here and not in the lists above.
Which would you rather facts are myths?
Popular lists repeat a handful of claims about the game and its famous dilemmas that don't hold up. Here's what the sources actually say.
| Myth | What's true |
|---|---|
| A 1990s book or board game invented would you rather. | John Burningham's picture book Would You Rather... came out in 1978, and Shakespeare used the form around 1599. A federal appeals court found such questions were in print before the brand. |
| President Obama answered the horse-sized duck question. | He didn't. It was among the most popular questions in his 2012 Reddit AMA, but he answered 10 others. |
| The horse-sized duck question started on Reddit. | It goes back to at least a 2003 British blog post quoting a newspaper reader's query. |
| Philippa Foot named the trolley problem. | Foot posed it in 1967. Judith Jarvis Thomson named it in 1976. |
| In the original trolley problem, you pull a lever. | In Foot's version you're the driver, steering. Thomson named the bystander-at-the-switch case in her 1985 article. |
| A Hobson's choice is a choice between two bad options. | It means take what's offered or nothing, after a Cambridge stable owner who let customers take only the horse nearest the door (Dictionary.com). |
| Jean Buridan wrote about a donkey stuck between two piles of hay. | The donkey is nowhere in his writings. Aristotle has an older version: a man equally hungry and thirsty, standing as far from food as from drink. |
| A dilemma has to have exactly two options. | In 2005, 42% of the American Heritage Dictionary's usage panel said it can cover more than two. |
Frequently asked questions
What are good would you rather questions?
+
The best ones split the room close to evenly, because both options are tempting or both cost something. "Weekly tests or daily homework?" is a good example: when YouGov asked US adults to imagine being a student again in 2023, they split 42% to 41%. For kids, pick two things they can picture, like a treehouse or a houseboat. For adults, trade-offs like more time or more money work best.
What is the hardest would you rather question?
+
The trolley problem: would you let a runaway trolley hit five people or steer it so it hits one? Philippa Foot posed it in 1967, and MIT's Moral Machine collected 40 million decisions on versions of it. For a family table, "more time or more money?" is a hard one that nobody finds upsetting.
What age is would you rather for?
+
From about three, with two familiar options a child can picture, like a puppy or a kitten. Imagined situations work from about six, when school starts asking children to back an opinion with a reason. Trade-offs suit 9 to 12, and the hard and deep questions are for teens and adults.
How many would you rather questions do you need?
+
About 10 for a short car ride and 15 to 20 for a 20-minute round, if everyone gives a one-sentence reason. For a classroom warm-up, one or two questions with time to defend each side is plenty.
What if a child says "neither"?
+
Let them change one detail of one option, then pick. A child who won't choose between a pet penguin and a pet sloth might take the penguin if it can live in the bathtub, and the reason for the change is usually the best answer of the night.
Are these would you rather questions okay for school?
+
Yes. None of them is about anyone's looks or body, or about anyone getting hurt, and there's a set written for students. They also work as opinion-writing prompts: Common Core asks first graders to state an opinion and give a reason, which is exactly what the game asks for.
Who invented would you rather?
+
Nobody. Shakespeare put one in Julius Caesar around 1599, John Burningham published a picture book called Would You Rather in 1978, and David Gomberg and Justin Heimberg's 1997 book made it a party game. A federal appeals court noted that such questions were in print before the name became a brand.